Damiani,+Zachary

Practice Debate 6/24:

2NC: Nice analysis on the China scenario, and overall strategic decisions in the 2NC. I think that if you write up the analysis you are doing into blocks that will help you out with speed organization. You are also making smart cross applications, good job! I think you could try to stay a little bit on the line-by-line which would help me flow you a little more clearly.

CX: I think that the poverty question you asked could be phrased a little differently, you need to be a little careful when discussing things like poverty and moral claim impacts. I really think this cross ex got a little off track for you.

2NR: Ok, I like your idea to drop the CP the best way to do this would just be to extend the perm as a test of competition. Good impact calc on the turbine DA, I think that you need to hedge a little against the 2AR plea to morals on poverty, you don't have a great response as to why poverty shouldn't be weighed first. Maybe just add a little of your case analysis to the impact calculous. Also your turbine impact is a war not an ecosystem loss impact, try to focus in on that to get a distinction with their impacts. Good plea to climate change inevitable, but make a distinction about why a nuke war would make this worse or why climate change will never lead to extinction. Good job!