Mulvaney,+Sam

Don't stop 1NC CX early! Good reading of the 1AC, but try to add some energy to your speaking voice - avoid monotone reading!
 * 6/25**

Cool stand up 1AR. Although, put the CP before the DA. Speed up - you can go faster than this. Work on time allocation - spend more time on DA and CP and impact out your args to how they interact with the impacts.


 * Round 6: Blaize DePass:** Aasim/Nisarg vs Noah/Sam

Sam (2NC)--I like your 2NC. I think that time allocation was great until you ended with :55 left on the clock. Other than that, all your analysis was good. You made all the arguments that you needed. I think you could've done a little more on the alternative debate and about solving their impacts but besides that this was a great speech!

Sam (2NR)--This was a great speech. I like your analysis and think the application is good. The thing to work on here is largely a question of impacts and impact comparison, which is something both sides need to end up doing. I think that when you include a discussion of impacts as well, you can really bring it home. Regardless, this was a good speech.

RFD: This debate had a lot of structural problems out of the 1NC. The neg reads 2AC perm cards on cap in the 1NC, which allows the aff to just extend those cards as offense and reasons why their aff solves cap. Also reading the cap K doesn't really work with the oil drilling good DA that has an impact of econ collapse bad. I give the aff that the perm solves best on the cap K and that the aff solves their impacts.
 * MDAW Tournament Round 1- Ruby**